Strawberry Cake with Custard – Sponge Filled with Fresh Berries

Strawberry Cake with Custard

☆ Rate it

In the height of berry season, it’s worth treating yourself to a delicious dessert and making a strawberry cake. We bake a good, fluffy sponge and fill it with ripe berries and custard. It’s a fairly simple cake: even a beginner can manage the sponge, and custard is one of the easiest creams there is. The berries must be ripe and sweet, so you don’t have to overload the strawberry cake with sugar. Thanks to my daughter for her help and for the recipe.

People often correct me that, going by this recipe, the pastry is more of a pie. I’ve settled it for myself this way: if the filling is baked together with the dough, it’s a pie. But if the finished dough is baked separately as a shell or layers and then spread or filled with the filling, it’s a cake. And believe me, once the dessert is served, it stops mattering altogether.

The base of the dessert is sponge cake. I’ve already written about how to make a good sponge batter . It’s probably the most common pastry dough, used for cake layers, tartlets, bases and so on. Lots of eggs, flour, sugar and a few additions, which usually just flavor the batter, make it fluffy and color it. For a cake you bake a loaf, round or another shape, and either cut it into layers or form it into a shell for the filling.

Almost any cream will do. It just has to be thick enough not to spread after chilling and to hold its shape. Custard is ideal. It’s made by a simple method: you “scald” a mixture of egg yolks, sugar and cornstarch in hot milk. The starch makes it easy to get a thick cream.

You need the ripest berries, freshly picked, not “wet” – too much juice is unwelcome. Larger berries are better, so you can cut them: that lets you use them both for the filling and for decoration. It’s highly desirable to use the sweetest strawberries you can find.

You can make a strawberry cake in several parallel stages. The sponge and the custard can be made at the same time. Once the sponge and cream have cooled, you can start assembling the cake. The crumb is scooped out of the baked sponge, and the cream with pieces of sweet strawberry goes in its place. Then the dessert needs to cool well and soak in the refrigerator. After that the cream becomes much firmer and no longer spreads, and the slices keep their shape when served.

Ingredients

6-8 servings

  • Ripe strawberries 300-400 g
  • For the sponge
  • Eggs 6
  • Sugar 6 tbsp (80 g)
  • Flour 1.5 cups (195 g)
  • Baking powder 0.5 sachet
  • Lemon zest 1 tbsp (6 g)
  • Butter or vegetable oil (for greasing the pan) 0.5 tbsp
  • For the cream
  • Egg yolks 5
  • Milk 0.5 l
  • Sugar 3-4 tbsp (41–55 g)
  • Cornstarch 2 tbsp (20 g)
  • Vanilla extract to taste

Step-by-step recipe

Sponge

  1. A strawberry cake isn’t hard to make, but it takes attention and care. The sponge should be tall and fluffy so that the inner space filled with berries and cream is large. For that, the batter uses baking powder – the ordinary store-bought kind. Better not to use baking soda: it’s very hard to guess the right amount, and the sponge ends up with an aftertaste.

    Strawberries.
  2. Whisk the eggs with the sugar. Put the contents of 6 eggs into a bowl or mixer bowl and add 6 tbsp sugar – about 150 g. Beat with a mixer until a thick foam forms and the eggs and sugar have increased in volume several times over. For better whisking, it’s best to keep the mixer bowl in very cold water.

    Egg and sugar foam.
  3. Make the batter. Sift the flour into a bowl and add the baking powder. The sachet usually states the amount of flour it’s meant for. For 1.5 cups of flour (195 g), no more than 200 g of wheat flour, work out the amount of baking powder the sponge needs. Mix the flour and baking powder and add the mixture to the egg foam.

    Preparing the sponge batter.

    Mix the batter thoroughly but gently with a spatula, from the bottom up, so the foam doesn’t deflate and there are no lumps. The batter will be runny and glossy. Grate the lemon zest into the liquid batter – it softens the smell and taste of egg – and mix once more.

    Since a strawberry cake is a sponge shell with a filling rather than layers, the batter should be a little thicker, with more flour.

  4. Prepare the baking pan: its height should be 2-2.5 times the thickness of the batter layer. Grease the bottom and sides with butter or vegetable oil and pour the batter into the pan.

    Liquid sponge batter.
  5. Bake the sponge in an oven preheated to 200°C. It usually takes 30-35 mins. After 20 mins, test it with a toothpick – if no batter sticks when you pierce it, the sponge is done. It’s also worth browning it a little. Take the finished sponge out of the oven and let it cool completely.

    Sponge for the cake.

Custard

  1. The cream can be cooked while the sponge is baking. It’s also quick and easy.

  2. Cook the custard. Pour half a liter of milk (250 ml) – store-bought 2.5% works – into a small saucepan and heat over medium heat. While the milk heats, mix 5 egg yolks with 2 tbsp cornstarch (20 g) and 3-4 tbsp sugar (41–55 g) in a tall glass. If the strawberries are sour, you can add more sugar – ideally the strawberry cake will not be too sweet, but have a slightly tart berry flavor. Stir the mixture thoroughly until the sugar dissolves completely. Pour the mixture in a thin stream into the milk as it comes to a boil, stirring constantly. Add liquid vanilla extract to taste. Custard thickens quickly, so you must keep stirring it, especially from the very bottom. After a few minutes, when the cream has thickened, remove it from the heat. To be sure there are no lumps, it’s worth straining it through a sieve. Let the cream cool well.

    Custard.

Assembling the cake

  1. Prepare the strawberries: hull the berries, wash them well and pat dry with napkins. We got the best result when each berry was cut in half lengthwise. That way the strawberries go perfectly with the custard without thinning it with juice, and they act as decoration for the strawberry cake.

  2. Prepare the cooled sponge for the filling. There are two options. The first is to slice off the top as a thin layer and scoop out the crumb with your fingers, forming a cavity for the filling. Then cover the cake with that lid and decorate it. The second option, which I like more, is not to use the top layer at all, leaving the surface of the cake with the cream and strawberries of the filling. By the way, the crumb is great with tea.

    Prepared sponge for the cake.
  3. Fill the sponge with cream and strawberries. With a spoon or spatula, coat the entire inside of the sponge with cream, carefully and without gaps. The cream should stick well to the sponge, in a layer 1-1.5 cm thick. Arrange strawberry halves on the cream in an even layer, and cover with a thick layer of cream. Add more strawberries and more cream.

    Filling of cream and strawberries.
  4. Decorate the top of the cake. Coat the top generously with custard and arrange the berry halves cut side up. For looks, it’s worth placing the strawberries symmetrically, pressing them lightly into the cream. The sides don’t need coating. However, if you decided to use the top of the sponge as a lid, coat it with cream, sprinkle with slightly dried crumbs and add a layer of strawberries. In this version it’s also better to coat the sides with cream.

    Cake with custard and fresh strawberries.
  5. Put the strawberry custard cake in the refrigerator. Custard sets well and becomes firm, a bit like a not-too-firm jelly. That lets you cut the strawberry cake into pieces and serve portions without worrying about the cream spreading. Ideally the cake should sit in the refrigerator overnight. At least a couple of hours – I understand that waiting is very hard when such a treat is right there!

    Strawberry cake

Serving

  1. If the dessert has cooled and soaked well, you can easily cut it into pieces and serve them separately. Use a small, very sharp knife so the berries in the filling get cut rather than crushed. If you like, decorate the slices with sprigs of fresh mint.

Calories and macros

415 kcal

Serving ≈ 270 g

  • Protein15 g15% of kcal
  • Fat13 g29% of kcal
  • Carbs57 g56% of kcal

100 g154 kcalProtein 5.6 gFat 4.8 gCarbs 21.2 g

Calculated from the recipe ingredients, excluding salt and spices. Data: USDA and Matvaretabellen.

Enjoyed the recipe? Pick me as a preferred source on Google, and you'll see my recipes more often in search. Choose on Google →
How did you like this recipe?
Thanks for rating!
Sorry you didn't like it

Leave your email and I'll write to find out what went wrong. A 1–2 rating counts only with an email. I won't publish it.

Tell us how it turned out
Made it? Tell us how it turned out — Sergey reads every review

The maximum upload file size: 10 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here