Broken Glass Jello Cake with Milk: No-Bake Recipe

Broken Glass Cake with Milk Jelly

☆ Rate it

I’ll admit I didn’t expect to like broken glass jello cake. It’s not really a dessert in the cake sense of the word, more of an elegant and tasty jelly. Most recipes use sour cream mixed with gelatin as the base. But to my taste, a delicate milk jelly is far better. Highly recommended!

“Cakes” like this are often called mosaic or stained glass, and I won’t argue, there’s a resemblance. A dense white base studded with big colorful “shards” of multicolored jelly is a treat for the eyes. The cake is no-bake, but the jelly takes time to set. What surprised me was how many options there are for the colored pieces.

How to make an easy no-bake cake from multicolored jellies and a milk base.

Ingredients

4–6 servings

For the colored jelly

  • Jelly mix in different colors 3–4 packets
  • Gelatin 10–12 g per packet
  • Water as directed on the packet

For the milk base

  • Milk, 2.5% 0.5 l
  • Gelatin 15–20 g
  • Sugar to taste
  • Vanilla to taste

Step-by-step recipe

Colored “shards”

The cake is easy to make, though you have a long wait while the jelly sets. For the colored “shards” of broken glass, you can buy a few ready-made jelly mixes, sold in stores. Or, more interestingly, you can set fruit juices with added gelatin and sugar.

  1. Buy 3–4 jelly mixes in different colors: yellow (lemon), green (kiwi), red (raspberry or cherry) and so on. The broken glass cake should be colorful.

    If you like, use orange, cherry or lemon juice and green tea: natural ingredients.

    Colored jellies: store-bought mixes or natural juices with gelatin, your choice.
  1. Get out 3–4 deep bowls. Pour one packet of jelly mix into each bowl and add 10–12 g of gelatin.

    Ready-made jelly mixes usually make perfectly tasty colorful desserts, but very soft ones, which makes them tricky to cut into cubes. So, and this matters, dissolve them in water with extra gelatin to make the finished jelly firmer.

    Powdered jelly mixes combined with extra gelatin and dissolved in water.
  2. Dissolve the mix in warm or hot water, in the amount given on the packet; the instructions are very clear. When all the powder has dissolved, strain the liquid and pour it into a wide flat-bottomed bowl or baking dish. The liquid should be 1.5–2 cm deep. Put all the dishes in the fridge until completely set. For the best set, leave the jelly in the cold for 5–6 hours.

    The jelly should be firm and not spread when pressed with a finger.

    The colored jellies need to set well.

Milk base

As I said, I skipped the sour cream for this cake. For the base I used ordinary 2.5% whole milk from the store.

  1. Ahead of time, soak 15–20 g of gelatin in lukewarm water and let it swell. That’s enough for 0.5 l of milk.

    Instant gelatin, prepared.
  2. Make the milk base. Pour the milk into a pot and bring to a boil. Add sugar and vanilla to taste. You can also add other flavorings, like “rum” or “lemon”. Once the milk has cooled a little but is still hot, stir in the swollen gelatin. The mixture will quickly become smooth. Strain the milk: boiled milk often forms a skin and foam. Let the mixture cool to room temperature.

    Milk with gelatin sets very well, so as soon as it has cooled to room temperature, assemble the cake right away.

    Milk mixed with gelatin, cooling to room temperature.

Assembling the cake

  1. Get out a few glass bowls or dishes with sloping sides. Take the colored jellies out of the fridge and cut them with the tip of a knife into 1.5–2 cm squares, right down to the bottom of the dish. Transfer all the jelly with a spatula to a large bowl and mix gently.

    Colored jelly cut into cubes that look like broken glass.
  1. Fill each bowl or dish with colored jelly cubes. Try to keep the cubes from sticking up above the rim. If needed, press them down a little with your palms.

    Molds filled with colored jelly.
  2. Be sure the milk mixture has cooled to room temperature by now. Carefully pour it into each mold over the jelly cubes, right to the brim.

    If some colored jelly sticks out above the surface, that’s fine.

    Molds filled with milk and gelatin.
  3. Put the molds in the fridge right away until fully set. And that’s it; all that’s left is to serve.

Serving

The jello cake comes out quite firm, so you can carefully cut it with a knife.

  1. Get a large flat plate ready for serving. Briefly dip the mold in warm water so the jelly touching the sides softens a little. Then just flip the mold, and the cake will drop out onto the plate.

    Broken glass cake
  2. Before serving, you can cut the jello cake into pieces. Decorate it with mint leaves or fresh berries.

    The dessert is colorful, and in cross-section it looks like stained glass.

Calories and macros

400 kcal

Serving ≈ 210 g

  • Protein16 g16% of kcal
  • Fat4 g9% of kcal
  • Carbs77 g75% of kcal

100 g188 kcalProtein 7.6 gFat 1.9 gCarbs 36.1 g

Calculated from the recipe ingredients, excluding salt and spices. Data: USDA and Matvaretabellen.

Enjoyed the recipe? Pick me as a preferred source on Google, and you'll see my recipes more often in search. Choose on Google →

How did you like this recipe?

Thanks for rating!
Sorry you didn't like it

Leave your email and I'll write to find out what went wrong. A 1–2 rating counts only with an email. I won't publish it.

Tell us how it turned out

To Get It Right

If the colored jelly is too soft

If the colored jellies for Broken Glass Cake turn out too soft to cut, you can reheat them, add more gelatin and let them set again.

Instead of packet jelly

For Broken Glass Cake you can use ready-made jelly candies or gummies in different colors, cut into pieces; many readers do it this way. Everything else stays the same.

With cookies

  • Add pieces of cookies, for example baked-milk flavored ones, to the colored jelly in Broken Glass Cake for a more filling cake.
  • Or lay cookies in a layer on the bottom of the mold and in the middle, between the cubes.

With fruit

Broken Glass Cake can also be made with fruit: add pieces of banana or canned peaches to the jelly cubes. Fresh pineapple and kiwi don’t work: gelatin sets poorly with them.

Have your own trick for this recipe?

Questions and answers

What is broken glass cake made of?

Cubes of multicolored jelly and a white gelatin base poured over them. The base is usually made with sour cream, but this recipe uses milk: to my taste, a delicate milk jelly is far better.

Can you make broken glass cake with sour cream?

Yes. Get sour cream that’s not too rich and not noticeably sour. Don’t boil it: mix it with sugar and gelatin that’s already dissolved and slightly cooled.

How long does broken glass cake take to set?

The colored jelly needs 5–6 hours in the fridge. After you pour in the milk mixture, the cake sets for another 3–4 hours; it’s easiest to leave it overnight.

How do you dissolve gelatin for broken glass cake?

Soak the gelatin in lukewarm water, let it swell, then stir it into the hot milk. 15–20 g of gelatin is enough for 0.5 l of milk, and each packet of colored jelly mix gets another 10–12 g.

Can you make broken glass cake with condensed milk?

Yes: replace some of the milk with condensed milk and add little or no sugar. 3–4 tbsp of condensed milk (60–80 g) is enough for 0.5 l of milk.

Didn't find an answer? Ask your question

Made it? Tell us how it turned out — Sergey reads every review

The maximum upload file size: 10 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here