Lemon Sandwich Cookies with Lemon Icing Filling – Easy Recipe

Lemon Sandwich Cookies

☆ 5

Homemade lemon cookies with a layer of sugar fondant are very easy to make. Really, all you need is everyday ingredients you already have at home, plus a bit of enthusiasm. These cookies smell wonderful and are perfect for a cup of tea at home. If you like, you can use any filling you want as the layer between two cookies pressed together like a sandwich.

At first we wanted to bake a layered sponge treat, like a lemon pastry, with a layer of cream or sugar fondant. But for various reasons we settled on a drier kind of bake. I made these with my daughter, and I’m very grateful to her for it. In the end we got very tasty, very fragrant sandwich cookies with a delicate lemon flavor. They go perfectly with tea, and with them my morning coffee was simply superb.

The dough contains no baking powder, so the cookies come out fairly dense but not hard. The flavor comes from lemon zest and concentrated lemon extract – it adds aroma, but you can do without it. You can add plain fresh lemon juice to the filling.

As a rule, cookies like these are baked fairly dry, so they keep for a long time. Then again, homemade lemon cookies never last – they get eaten quickly. They don’t have to be round: if you have cookie cutters in various shapes, you can even hang the dry cookies on the Christmas tree for New Year. Or tie a stack of them with a ribbon as a gift for friends – that’s what they do in Finland, for example, treating each other to piparkakut gingerbread cookies.

I recommend a rich, dense sugar dough rather than a crumbly shortcrust like the one for grated pie. It contains sugar and a little butter, which makes it sweet and not too hard.

Let the prepared dough rest a little so the gluten in the flour can swell, and it’s best to work with it while it’s cold. To shape the cookies you need cookie cutters. I once bought a set of about a dozen in all sorts of shapes. They were inexpensive, yet surprisingly handy and made of sturdy plastic. Bake on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper.

Ingredients

12-15 pcs

For the filling

  • Powdered sugar 0.5 cup (60 g)
  • Butter 30 g (1 tbsp)
  • Lemon juice 1 tbsp (from 1 lemon)

For the dough

  • Butter 100 g
  • Sugar (white or brown) 0.5 cup (90 g)
  • Egg 1
  • Lemon zest from half a lemon
  • Vanilla, lemon extract to taste (the extract is optional)
  • Wheat flour 2 cups (plus more for dusting the table) (260 g)

Step-by-step recipe

How to make the cream filling

First make the cream filling, then put it in the fridge. To keep the fondant soft, we add a little butter. If the filling isn’t chilled, it will be hard to spread and will run.

  1. Make the filling. Take the butter out of the fridge ahead of time so it softens. Put the powdered sugar in a small bowl, add 1 tbsp of softened butter and squeeze in 1 tbsp of lemon juice.

    Sugar fondant.

    Mix the fondant thoroughly with a spatula or fork until completely smooth. You can use a mixer if you like, but carefully – the dry mixture loves to fly everywhere. You should get a white paste. Don’t add water; if necessary, it’s better to add a few drops of juice. Put the cream filling in the fridge.

    Lemon filling.

How to make the dough

  1. Mix the butter, sugar and egg. While the lemon cream chills, mix the softened butter (about 100 g should be left), sugar (white or brown), vanilla, concentrated lemon extract and the grated zest of half a lemon. Add the egg. Beat everything with a mixer fitted with dough hooks until completely smooth.

    Making the dough.
  2. Knead the dough. Sift the wheat flour. Add about 1.5 cups of flour (195 g) to the creamed mixture and keep kneading. Then it’s best to continue kneading on the table by hand, adding the remaining flour in small portions. The dough should be fairly firm and not stick to your hands or the table.

    Adding the flour.

How to shape and bake the cookies

  1. Chill the dough and cut out the cookies. It’s better to let the dough chill a little, about 20 mins in the fridge – it’s easier to work with that way. Dust the table with flour and roll out a small piece of dough with a rolling pin into a sheet 5-7 mm thick. Cut out cookies with the cutter of your choice. Knead the scraps together again and use them for more cookies. By the way, if you decide to make lemon cookies in different shapes, try to get an even number of each. The number of cookies depends on their size and the thickness of the dough. Keep in mind that each “sandwich” needs two cookies.

    Cutting out the cookies for baking.
  2. Bake for 12-15 mins. Preheat the oven to 160-170°C. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper, transfer the cookies onto it and put it in the oven. The cookies should turn light golden. Keep an eye on them so the bottoms don’t start to burn.

    Baking the cookies until done.

How to assemble the cookies

  1. Sandwich the cookies with the filling. The baked cookies should cool completely. The filling should spread easily: if it has hardened in the fridge, leave it at room temperature for a few minutes. Spread one cookie with the cream filling – 0.5-1 tsp is enough. Cover with another cookie and press lightly. The filling shouldn’t squeeze out of the gap. If the filling runs, chill it longer.

    Spreading the cookies with cream.

Serving

  1. Decorate if you like. You can also cover the tops of the lemon cookies with the same cream, like a glaze. Or dust them with powdered sugar before serving.

    Lemon cookies

    Lemon cookies are best kept in a cool, dry place. But it’s better to bake them in small batches so they stay fresh. If you like, you can use lime or orange instead of lemon.

How did you like this recipe?

Rate it with one tap.

Thanks for rating!
Sorry you didn't like it

Leave your email and I'll write to find out what went wrong. A 1–2 rating counts only with an email. I won't publish it.

Tell us how it turned out

Calories and macros

474 kcal

100 g

  • Protein6.4 g5% of kcal
  • Fat21.1 g40% of kcal
  • Carbs64.1 g54% of kcal

Calculated from the recipe ingredients, excluding salt and spices. Data: USDA and Matvaretabellen.

Made it? Tell me how it turned out — I read every review

The maximum upload file size: 10 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here