Homemade Shortbread Cookies with Butter and Walnuts

Homemade Shortbread Cookies

☆ 4.7

Shortbread cookies take 2 cups of flour, 150 g of butter, 150 g of sugar, an egg and toasted ground walnuts. I chop the butter into the flour, rub it into crumbs and quickly knead the dough, then 30–45 minutes in the fridge. A 6–8 mm sheet, 20–25 minutes at 180°C.

As a kid, I loved homemade shortbread cookies with fresh milk. My grandmother had a small electric oven where she baked crumbly cookies, little hand pies or honey gingerbread. To be honest, most of the time we made do with store-bought cookies and Artek wafers with white or dark filling — I liked the white ones better.

Grandma never used margarine for her shortbread; she preferred butter. Later I found out that her recipe is very close to French sablé cookies. Sablés are a traditional shortcrust bake, round with a fluted edge. Sablé dough is usually half flour and half butter and sugar by volume. Often the cookies get a filling of jam or preserves — most often citrus — or are made with nuts, dried berries and so on.

Dough is the foundation of bread making and pastry. It is a moist mixture of flour and a wide range of additions, and water or other liquids are not always on the ingredient list. The most common is enriched yeast dough, which we use for poppy seed buns or cinnamon rolls. Choux pastry goes into eclairs and cream puffs. Puff pastry is the base for strudel.

Shortcrust is a special kind of homemade dough made of flour and fat. We usually make it for grated pie with currant jam. In French cuisine, shortcrust is called brisée — it is firm, doesn’t stick to your hands at all, and is easy to shape into the most intricate forms if you have the right cutter. Italian cuisine has a wonderful apple tart on a brisée base — crostata.

The dough for crumbly cookies is made without water or milk. Just wheat flour, butter and eggs. Homemade shortbread can be baked from dough made in advance — it keeps well in the fridge for some time. If you like, add nuts, raisins or other extras. Whenever possible, make the cookies without margarine, baking powder or baking soda — they noticeably affect the taste and aroma.

Butter shortbread cookies. A simple, easy bake. Step-by-step recipe with photos of a tasty teatime treat.

Ingredients

700 g of cookies

  • Wheat flour 2 cups (260 g)
  • Butter 150 g
  • Sugar 150 g
  • Egg 1
  • Walnuts (shelled) 50 g
  • Baking powder optional
  • Vanilla or vanilla sugar optional

Step-by-step recipe

Making the dough

  1. Prepare the ingredients. Sift the top-grade wheat flour. Sifting removes any leftover bran, unwanted particles and lumps. It also makes the flour light and fluffy and aerates it. Take the butter and eggs out of the fridge so they come to room temperature.

    Flour, butter, eggs and sugar.
  2. Make the dry mix. Lightly toast the walnuts in a dry pan until they smell pleasantly nutty. Grind them in a mortar or blender into fine crumbs. In a bowl, combine the flour, ground nuts and sugar. If you like, add baking powder, a pinch of vanilla or a packet of vanilla sugar. Mix thoroughly so everything is evenly distributed.

    There is a lot of debate about whether shortcrust needs baking powder. I once read that if the bake is going to be thicker than 1 cm, it’s worth adding a packet of baking powder to the flour. So it’s up to you. Just remember that store-bought baking powder is a balanced mix containing ammonium carbonate, designed to turn completely into gas without leaving a trace. But it doesn’t keep long, so it has to be fresh. Better not to use baking soda — the aftertaste will remain no matter how hard you try.

    Dry mixture for the cookies.
  3. Work in the butter and egg. Chop the butter into pieces with a knife and add it to the flour. Use a fork or a wooden spatula to work the butter into the flour. You’ll get coarse crumbs or small clumps of flour and fat.

    Flour with butter.

    Crack the egg into the bowl and work the mixture again. At first it may seem that the dough needs some milk, but don’t add any. You’ll need to work the shortcrust for quite a while until it is completely smooth.

    Adding the egg to the dough.
  4. Knead the dough. Dust the table with flour and tip the whole contents of the bowl onto it. For tender, crumbly cookies, gently but thoroughly work the crumbs with your hands until the dough is completely smooth. Don’t knead it for too long — it can separate and lose its elasticity.

    Working the dough on the table.
  5. Chill the dough. Roll the smooth dough into a ball and wrap it in cling film. Refrigerate for 30–45 mins. As it chills, the butter firms up a little and cutting out the cookies becomes much easier. The dough won’t stick to the cutters or get stuck in small crevices — cookie cutters can come in quite fancy shapes.

    Finished shortcrust dough.

Shaping the cookies

  1. Shape the cookies. Once chilled, take the dough out of the fridge and discard the film. Lightly dust the table with flour and roll or press the dough into a thin sheet, 6–8 mm thick. Shape the cookies while the dough is still cold. If you don’t have cookie cutters, you can simply roll the dough into a log and slice it into thin rounds with a knife. Or shape a thin, wide loaf and cut it crosswise.

    Cookie cutouts.

Baking

  1. Preheat the oven to 180 °C. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Since the dough contains a lot of butter, there’s no need to grease the paper. Arrange the cookies on the baking sheet and put it in the hot oven.

    Cookies on a baking sheet.
  2. Bake the cookies. Shortcrust cookies bake quickly — in 20–25 mins they are done. If you like, let them brown a little. The main thing is not to burn them. It’s very hard to catch the moment when the sweet vanilla flavor turns into the taste of burnt dough. So it’s better not to experiment.

    Golden-brown cookies.

    Let the baked cookies cool. While hot, they may not be crumbly and short. Once completely cool, they will show all these qualities in full.

    Freshly baked cookies.

Serving

  1. Make your favorite tea with lemon or warm some milk. Put the homemade shortbread cookies in a wicker basket lined with a cloth napkin and serve. Your evening tea will be a real treat.

    Shortbread cookies

How did you like this recipe?

Rate it with one tap.

Thanks for rating!
Sorry you didn't like it

Leave your email and I'll write to find out what went wrong. A 1–2 rating counts only with an email. I won't publish it.

Tell us how it turned out

Calories and macros

517 kcal

100 g

  • Protein7.2 g6% of kcal
  • Fat27.8 g48% of kcal
  • Carbs59.5 g46% of kcal

Calculated from the recipe ingredients, excluding salt and spices. Data: USDA and Matvaretabellen.

To Get It Right

Add-ins

Swap the nuts for raisins or dried berries. As with French sablés, you can sandwich the cookies in pairs with jam or preserves — citrus works best. If you want to taste the nuts more, grind them a little coarser.

Make the dough ahead

Shortcrust keeps well in the fridge for some time, wrapped in cling film. Make it the night before and bake the cookies when you need them.

How to store the cookies

Keep the cooled cookies in a tin or a jar with a lid so they don’t go soft or pick up other smells.

Have your own trick for this recipe?

Questions and answers

How long do you bake shortbread cookies?

20–25 minutes in an oven preheated to 180 °C. You can let them brown a little, but don’t overbake: burnt dough changes the flavor right away.

Why did my shortbread cookies turn out hard?

Usually it’s too much flour or kneading too long. Don’t add more than 2 cups of flour (260 g), and work the dough only until smooth. And don’t judge them hot — they turn crumbly once completely cool.

Can I make shortbread cookies with margarine?

Yes, in the same amount — 150 g. But my grandmother always baked these cookies with butter: with margarine the taste and aroma are noticeably worse.

Can I make shortbread cookies without baking powder?

Yes, baking powder is optional in this recipe. Cookies 6–8 mm thick come out crumbly without it, and taste and smell even better. Don’t use baking soda instead — it leaves an aftertaste.

Do you add salt to shortbread cookies?

To taste. I don’t add salt, but if you like, add a pinch to the flour.

Didn't find an answer? Ask your question

Made it? Tell me how it turned out — I read every review

The maximum upload file size: 10 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here