Beef and Turkey Aspic Without Gelatin (Kholodets) Recipe

Beef and Turkey Aspic (Kholodets)

☆ Rate it

How long to cook beef aspic?

Beef and turkey aspic cooks in two stages: the beef shank broth for 1.5–2 hours over very low heat, so the liquid barely moves, and then the turkey breast in the strained broth for about 2 hours more, until the meat is very soft. A beef leg has so much gelatin that the aspic sets without any additions.

I make this beef and turkey kholodets for festive meals, and it needs no gelatin. It all rests on a stock made from beef shank: the joint and hoof hold so many gelling substances that the aspic sets like glass.

The key is to simmer the stock over the lowest heat, so it barely moves. Then the kholodets comes out clear, and if the stock does turn cloudy, you can clarify it with egg white. I serve it with mustard and mashed potatoes.

Ingredients

8-10 servings

For the stock

  • Beef shank 1
  • Cold water for cooking the meat 4–5 l
  • Carrot 1
  • Onion 1
  • Eggs (if you need to clarify the stock) 2

For the meat and seasoning

  • Large turkey breast fillet (up to 1 kg) 1
  • Bay leaf 1-2
  • Black pepper 5-6 peppercorns, plus more to taste
  • Garlic 1-2 cloves
  • Salt to taste

For the mold and serving

  • Carrot, hard-boiled egg, herbs optional
  • Table mustard, mashed potatoes for serving

Step-by-step recipe

Beef shank stock

It’s a simple way to make kholodets without any gelatin. The base of the dish is a rich, very dense stock made from beef shank, joint and hoof. This part of the leg holds the most gelling substances.

  1. Prepare the shank and bring it to a boil. Chop the beef shank into large pieces, rinse and place in a large pot. Pour in 4-5 l of cold water and bring to a boil. Skim off the foam, and if the first stock turns very cloudy, you can drain it, rinse the shank and cover it with fresh water.

  2. Simmer the stock with the vegetables. Peel an onion and a carrot and add them to the water. Better not to use the onion skin – it will color the stock more than you’d like. Cook the stock for 1.5-2 hours over very low heat, without covering the pot tightly: the liquid should barely “tremble” and never boil hard. This is how you get a really clear aspic.

  3. Strain the stock and throw away the vegetables. Take out the beef as well – if there is meat left on the bones, you can eat it with mustard, it’s delicious.

Clarifying the stock

If the stock is clear, there’s no need to clarify it – go straight on to cooking the turkey in it.

  1. Clarify the stock with egg white. Whisk two egg whites into a foam and mix with eggshells crushed in a mortar. Cool the stock to almost room temperature, stir in the egg whites and heat over low heat. Gradually the whites will set and “bind” the particles that make the stock cloudy. The stock clarifies very effectively; then strain it twice through a thick cloth.

Turkey

  1. Cook the turkey in the stock. Cut the turkey fillet into 4-6 pieces and add to the stock. Add 1-2 bay leaves and 5-6 black peppercorns. Simmer the turkey for about 2 hours over low heat: the fillet should start to fall apart and the meat should become very tender.

    In total the aspic cooks for 3.5-4 hours: 1.5-2 hours for the shank and about 2 hours for the turkey.

  2. Pull the meat apart and place it in the mold. Take the turkey out of the stock and pull it into large fibers or cut it with a knife into thin, long strips, as is usual for turkey aspic. Place the meat in a mold or a dish of suitable size. If you like, you can first put slices of carrot, halves of hard-boiled egg and herbs in the mold.

Pouring and setting

  1. Season the stock and strain it. Season the stock with salt and pepper to taste. Crush 1-2 garlic cloves and add them to the slightly cooled but still hot stock. After 10 minutes, strain the stock through a thick cloth to filter out the bits of garlic, pepper, bay leaf and leftover turkey.

  2. Pour the stock over the turkey pieces in the prepared dish and let it cool to room temperature.

  3. Put the dish in the fridge until fully set. The eternal question – will it set or not? Beef leg has so much gelatin that the beef and turkey aspic will be as firm and clear as glass. Usually the aspic sets firmly in 2-3 hours, but for the best result it’s worth keeping it in the cold longer.

Serving

  1. Cut the aspic into portions with a knife. You can serve it in individual portions on plates or in one large dish with a spatula. Serve the aspic with table mustard – that’s how it tastes best. As a side, we serve mashed potatoes.

How did you like this recipe?

No one has rated it yet — be the first.

Thanks for rating!
Sorry you didn't like it

Leave your email and I'll write to find out what went wrong. A 1–2 rating counts only with an email. I won't publish it.

Tell us how it turned out

Calories and macros

315 kcal

Serving ≈ 280 g

  • Protein59 g78% of kcal
  • Fat7 g20% of kcal
  • Carbs2 g3% of kcal

100 g113 kcalProtein 20.9 gFat 2.3 gCarbs 0.8 g

Calculated from the recipe ingredients, excluding salt and spices. Data: USDA and Matvaretabellen.

Made it? Tell me how it turned out — I read every review

The maximum upload file size: 10 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here

To Get It Right

Which meat to use

For the stock, a beef shank with the joint and hoof: this part of the leg holds the most gelling substances, and the aspic sets on its own. The meat left on the bone doesn’t go into the aspic; you can eat it with mustard, it’s delicious. For the aspic itself, a large turkey breast fillet, up to 1 kg: after the long simmer it falls apart into fibers, and the meat in the aspic comes out very tender.

Salt, pepper and garlic

Salt the stock at the very end, once the turkey is cooked: over the long simmer it reduces noticeably, and an aspic salted at the start is easy to oversalt. I don’t leave garlic in the aspic: crush 1-2 cloves into the hot stock, leave for 10 minutes and strain through a thick cloth. The flavor and aroma stay, but there are no bits.

For the holiday table

You can pour the aspic into one large dish and serve it with a spatula, or straight into individual plates or small molds, which is handier on the table. For a prettier look, put slices of carrot, halves of hard-boiled egg and herbs in the bottom of the mold before the meat. Serve with table mustard, that’s how it tastes best; our side is mashed potatoes.

Making ahead

Kholodets is best made the day before: cooking takes about 4 hours, it sets in the fridge in 2-3 hours, and best of all overnight. On the morning of the holiday all that’s left is to cut and plate it.

Other aspics on the site

Related recipes: kholodets and turkey aspic, where the turkey is pulled the same way, into thin long strips.

Have your own trick for this recipe?

Questions and answers

How to make beef aspic clear?

The main thing is not to let the stock boil: over the lowest heat it should barely “tremble” the whole time it cooks. Skim the foam as soon as it comes to a boil; if the first stock turns very cloudy, drain it, rinse the shank and cover it with fresh water. Don’t add onion skin, it colors the stock. And if the stock still turns cloudy, clarify it with egg whites and crushed shells and strain it twice through a thick cloth.

Should aspic be cooked with the lid on or off?

Don’t cover the pot tightly: under a closed lid the stock boils harder, while it should barely move, or the aspic will turn cloudy. Shift the lid to leave a gap.

How much meat and water do I need for aspic?

For 8-10 servings: one beef shank, a turkey fillet of up to 1 kg and 4-5 l of cold water. Pour in all the water at once and don’t top it up while cooking: the less is left at the end, the firmer the aspic.

Can I make this aspic with chicken instead of turkey?

Yes, in the same beef shank stock. Cook the chicken fillet until it starts to fall apart into fibers; chicken needs noticeably less time than turkey. Then proceed as in the recipe.

What if the aspic doesn’t set?

That happens when there was too much water or the stock was simmered too briefly and too gently. Pour the stock back into the pot, boil it and reduce by about a third, pour it over the meat again and chill. The quickest fix is to dissolve gelatin in the hot stock according to the package, but with a shank it’s usually not needed. To be sure, put a spoonful of stock in the fridge for 15-20 minutes before pouring: if it thickens, the whole aspic will set.

How long does aspic keep, and can it be frozen?

In the fridge, covered with a lid or cling film, 3-4 days, so for a holiday you can safely make it a day or two ahead. Freezing isn’t a good idea: after thawing, the jelly weeps and turns cloudy.

Didn't find an answer? Ask your question