Old Bay Chicken Wings – Baked, with Hot Butter Sauce

Old Bay Chicken Wings Baked in the Oven

☆ Rate it

Baked chicken wings made this way are often called Maryland Old Bay wings, a nod to where the recipe comes from. It may sound a little exotic, but every ingredient is easy to find. Old Bay seasoning is a legend of American cooking, created in Baltimore almost 100 years ago. Its main components are celery salt and sweet and hot peppers. The exact blend is kept secret, and it is said to contain up to 20 ingredients. The hot sauce used in the authentic version is easy to replace at home with something similar, as there is plenty to choose from. And most importantly, the baked wings turn out simply delicious!

Ingredients

2 servings

  • For the wings
  • Chicken wings 1 kg
  • Old Bay seasoning 1 tbsp
  • Baking powder 1 tsp (optional) (5 g)
  • Salt 1 tsp (6 g)
  • Vegetable oil 0.5-1 tbsp
  • For the sauce
  • Butter 2 tbsp
  • Cayenne pepper hot sauce 2 tbsp
  • Worcestershire sauce 2 tbsp
  • Old Bay seasoning 0.5-1 tsp
  • To serve
  • Celery stalks 2-3
  • Carrot 1
  • Green onions 2-3
  • Tomato sauce (preferably mild) 3-4 tbsp

Step-by-step recipe

How to prepare and marinate the wings

  1. For Old Bay chicken wings it is best to buy a pack of wings without the tips, since they are usually not used in dishes anyway. Old Bay seasoning is sold in stores; it has a really interesting aroma and flavor, and I liked it a lot. It is actually marketed for seafood and chicken. The hot sauce used in authentic recipes is Frank’s RedHot, the most popular brand of medium-hot sauce and a must for Buffalo wings; it is made from cayenne pepper. By the way, the sauce and the seasoning come from the same manufacturer. You can swap it for a similar sauce such as Crystal Hot Sauce, which is also popular and easy to find.

    Chicken wings, sauces and seasonings.
  2. Prepare the wings: rinse them and pat dry with paper towels. It is best to cut off the tips, as there is hardly anything to eat there; use them for soup instead. Cut the wings at the joints into drumettes and flats and put them in a bowl.

  3. Marinate the wings. Mix the spices: 1 tbsp of Old Bay seasoning, 1 tsp of baking powder (5 g) (half a packet; optional, it helps the skin crisp up) and 1 tsp of fine salt (6 g). Toss the chicken with the spices, cover the bowl with plastic wrap and refrigerate for 6-8 hours, or better still overnight.

    Wings tossed with spices, ready to go into the fridge.

How to roast the wings

  1. Preheat the oven to 200-210°C and arrange the wings in a baking dish. I use an ovenproof glass one, because a metal pan always overcooks the underside of the meat. Lining the dish with foil is often recommended; that is up to you. Take the wings out of the fridge and pour off any liquid that has collected. Add 0.5-1 tbsp of vegetable oil, mix well and arrange the wing pieces in a single layer.

    Wings arranged in a baking dish, ready for the oven.
  2. Roast in the oven until the wings have a golden, slightly crispy skin. Stir them with a spatula now and then so they brown more evenly. The wings usually take 40-45 mins, but it is worth giving them a little longer so they get more color. Just make sure they do not stick to the dish, and do not overcook them either, or they will dry out.

    Wings roasted until golden brown.

How to make the sauce and toss the wings

  1. You do not need much sauce, just enough to coat the wings all over before serving. I make a bit more, use part of it and mix the rest with a good mild tomato sauce to serve alongside the wings for dipping.

  2. Make the sauce while the wings finish roasting. In a small bowl, mix 2 tbsp each of hot sauce, Worcestershire sauce and melted (but not hot) butter. Add 0.5-1 tsp of Old Bay seasoning and mix thoroughly. The sauce turns out smooth and glossy.

    Hot butter sauce for the wings.
  3. Toss the wings in the sauce: transfer the roasted wings to a deep bowl, add half of the sauce and toss well so it coats them evenly. Unlike Buffalo wings, this version needs no further cooking once the sauce is added.

    Wings tossed in the sauce.

Serving

  1. Arrange the wings on a large plate and make the dipping sauce. Since celery seed is the main ingredient in Old Bay seasoning, you can lay the wings on fresh celery leaves. Mix the rest of the sauce with a good tomato sauce, preferably a mild one, add a pinch of finely chopped green onion and pour it into a small bowl. Set the bowl of sauce right on the plate next to the roasted wings.

    Old Bay chicken wings
  2. Serve with cut vegetables. As a side I like fresh vegetables, usually carrot and juicy celery stalks cut into sticks. You can also add crisp seasonal vegetables such as radishes, cucumber, tomato and so on, as well as fresh herbs. Serve the wings while they are hot; no need for forks, they are easy to eat with your hands.

Calories and macros

815 kcal

Serving ≈ 290 g

  • Protein58 g29% of kcal
  • Fat58 g66% of kcal
  • Carbs9 g5% of kcal

100 g279 kcalProtein 19.8 gFat 19.9 gCarbs 3.1 g

Calculated from the recipe ingredients, excluding salt and spices. Data: USDA and Matvaretabellen.

Enjoyed the recipe? Pick me as a preferred source on Google, and you'll see my recipes more often in search. Choose on Google →
How did you like this recipe?
Thanks for rating!
Sorry you didn't like it

Leave your email and I'll write to find out what went wrong. A 1–2 rating counts only with an email. I won't publish it.

Tell us how it turned out
Made it? Tell us how it turned out — Sergey reads every review

The maximum upload file size: 10 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here