Homemade Assorted Pizza with Different Toppings

Homemade Assorted Pizza

☆ Rate it

A homemade assorted pizza baked in the oven, with different toppings for every member of the family, is the answer when tastes are just too different. Simply give everyone their own patch of dough and let them top it however they like.

No other food can compete with home cooking, not even restaurant food. Professionally cooked meals from restaurants and cafés are hard to come by, simply because you can’t eat out all the time, and I won’t even mention fast food, although the reasons to avoid it are somewhat different. But, as it turns out, cooking at home from simple ingredients is easy and even fun.

Sadly, in recent years all sorts of frivolous places have been hiding behind a “home cooking” sign. For example, they might bake a “homemade” pie in a café’s factory-like kitchen, which is a bit like selling you hake and calling it pike-perch. The pie will be tasty, but it won’t be homemade. If your loved ones prefer pizza with different toppings, nothing stops you from making an assorted one that takes into account your family’s tastes, wishes and even quirks. Besides, baking a pizza with lots of toppings is a fascinating process that kids especially love.

We gave it a try. It was great!!! In the end, our homemade assorted pizza turned into an incredible mix of pizza diavola, pizza margherita and an amazing mushroom pizza. Everyone was happy! Not a single slice was left.

A homemade assorted pizza just the way you want it, and not only you but your whole family. Your pizza will turn out better than at a pizzeria and exactly to your taste.

Ingredients

1 pizza, 34 cm

Dough

  • Premium wheat flour 2 cups (260 g)
  • Lukewarm water 180 ml
  • Instant yeast 5 g
  • Salt 1/2 tsp (3 g)
  • Sugar 2 tsp (9 g)
  • Olive oil 3 tbsp
  • Vegetable oil for the pan 1–2 tsp

Pizza sauce

  • Tomatoes 2–3
  • Garlic 2 cloves
  • Sugar 1 tsp (5 g)
  • Olive oil 1 tbsp
  • Dried oregano 0.5 tsp
  • Salt, black pepper, chili to taste

Toppings

  • Salami 50 g
  • Button mushrooms 4–5
  • Fresh basil 2–3 sprigs
  • Olive oil 2 tbsp
  • Parmesan 50 g
  • Tomato 1
  • Black olives 6–8
  • Green olives 5–6
  • Hot pepper 1
  • Cherry tomatoes 5–6
  • Oregano to taste

Step-by-step recipe

Making the dough

This yeast pizza dough is simple and always turns out, and the crust of the finished pizza can be thin or fluffy, crispy or soft, as you like. The pan diameter is 32–34 cm.

  1. Mix the dry ingredients. Sift 2 cups of premium wheat flour (260 g) into a large bowl. Add 0.5 tsp of fine salt (3 g) and 2 tsp of sugar (9 g), and sprinkle in half a packet of instant dry yeast, 5 g. This kind of yeast, meant to be mixed straight into dry flour, is usually sold in 11 g sachets. Stir the dry ingredients with a fork so they are evenly distributed.

    Adding salt, sugar and yeast to the flour.
  2. Pour 180 ml of lukewarm water into a glass; warm cold water in the microwave for 10–15 seconds. Add 3 tbsp of olive oil to the water, stir and pour it into the flour right away. Knead a soft dough, adding flour in small portions. The dough should be very soft and not stick to your hands.

  3. Let the dough rise. Roll the dough into a ball, dust the bottom of the bowl with flour and place the dough on it. Cover the bowl with a towel and leave it in a warm place for 40–45 mins. The dough rises well: after this time, punch it down, adding a little flour. Cover the bowl with a towel and put it back in a warm place.

    Risen pizza dough.
  4. Put the dough in the pan. Prepare a pizza pan by greasing it with 1–2 tsp of vegetable oil. Turn the dough out onto a floured table and press it with your hands into a circle. Carefully transfer the dough to the pan, stretching it to the rim. Try to form a thicker, rolled edge around the border.

    Pizza dough.

Sauce for homemade pizza

If you don’t have a good tomato sauce, I suggest making one from fresh tomatoes. Tomato sauce made from ripe tomatoes tastes much better. You need red tomatoes with as few seeds as possible (there are special meaty varieties) and without white parts inside. The sauce from 2–3 large tomatoes is enough for one pizza.

  1. Peel the tomatoes. If they are large enough, you can simply peel them with a knife. Or put them in a bowl, pour boiling water from the kettle over them for 2–3 mins, then rinse with cold water and remove the outer skin, which looks like plastic film. Finely chop the tomato flesh with a knife or blend it into a puree.

  2. Make the sauce. Heat olive oil in a saucepan and fry 1–2 peeled and crushed garlic cloves in it. Then discard the garlic. Add the finely chopped hot pepper to the oil and pour in the tomato puree. Season the sauce with salt and pepper, and add 0.5 tsp of dried oregano and 1 tsp of sugar (5 g). Simmer covered over the lowest heat: the sauce should become thick, fragrant and, most importantly, smooth.

    Simmering the sauce.

Toppings

And then, as the TV hero Alf used to say, the fun for the whole family begins: laying out the toppings on the pizza according to everyone’s individual tastes, however each person likes it.

  1. Divide the dough circle into 4 sections.

    Everything for the toppings.

    Spread the pizza sauce over the dough.

    Spreading sauce over the dough.
  2. For the first layer, lay out sliced tomatoes and salami: two sections of tomatoes and two sections of salami.

    Laying out salami and tomato.

    Sprinkle all sections with chopped fresh basil leaves and dried oregano.

    Sprinkling with basil.

    Add the black and green olives. This gives you four combinations: salami and black olives, salami and green olives, tomato and black olives, tomato and green olives.

    Laying out the olives.
  3. Finish the toppings. Add the cherry tomato halves, with the seeds removed first. Scatter raw button mushrooms, cut into thin slices. Everyone wanted mushrooms, so our pizza had mushrooms all over.

    Laying out the mushrooms.

    Sprinkle the whole pizza with finely grated Parmesan. Drizzle with olive oil. To visually mark the borders between sections with different toppings, lay out thin strips of seeded, lightly fried hot pepper.

    Sprinkling the pizza with cheese.

Baking

  1. Place the assorted pizza in an oven preheated to 180–190°C and bake for up to 20 mins. After 15 mins, check whether it’s done, judging by the dough.

Serving

  1. Cut the finished pizza into 4 pieces along the borders marked by the hot pepper strips.

    Cutting the pizza.

    Top with fresh basil leaves.

    Homemade pizza

    Serve the homemade assorted pizza right away, while it’s hot. Everyone grab your own piece!

How did you like this recipe?

No one has rated it yet — be the first.

Thanks for rating!
Sorry you didn't like it

Leave your email and I'll write to find out what went wrong. A 1–2 rating counts only with an email. I won't publish it.

Tell us how it turned out

Calories and macros

206 kcal

100 g

  • Protein5.7 g11% of kcal
  • Fat11.2 g50% of kcal
  • Carbs19.6 g39% of kcal

Calculated from the recipe ingredients, excluding salt and spices. Data: USDA and Matvaretabellen.

Made it? Tell me how it turned out — I read every review

The maximum upload file size: 10 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here

To Get It Right

Which cheese to use

For an assorted pizza with different cheeses in the sections, it depends on the cheese: a hard one like Parmesan is best grated. A soft one, such as mozzarella, can be sliced.

To keep the edges from sticking

The pizza pan is greased with 1–2 tsp of oil. If you bake on parchment and the edges of the pizza stick, rub it generously with butter or use non-stick parchment with a wax coating.

Instead of olive oil

Instead of olive oil, ordinary sunflower oil works in the pizza too: readers have tried it, and it still turns out delicious.

Have your own trick for this recipe?

Questions and answers

What goes into an assorted pizza?

It’s a pizza with different toppings on one crust: each family member gets their own section. We had 4 sections: salami or tomato, black or green olives, with mushrooms, basil and Parmesan over the whole pizza.

Can I use tomato paste instead of sauce?

Yes. Readers mix 3 tbsp of tomato paste (50 g) with 3 tbsp of water, add oregano, dried garlic and a pinch of salt, and spread it over the base. But a sauce made from fresh ripe tomatoes tastes much better.

What seasonings go on pizza?

In this recipe, dried oregano and fresh basil, plus garlic, black pepper and hot chili in the sauce. The basil goes on twice: chopped over the toppings and as fresh leaves on the finished pizza.

How do you know when pizza is done?

Go by the dough: check it after 15 minutes of baking. The pizza is ready when the rolled edge is golden and the bottom is baked through.

Can you put raw mushrooms on pizza?

Yes, the button mushrooms in this recipe go on raw, just cut into thin slices: they have time to cook while the pizza bakes.

Didn't find an answer? Ask your question