Stuffed Peppers in Sour Milk Sauce - Oven Recipe

Stuffed Peppers Baked in Sour Milk Sauce

☆ Rate it

Nobody knows where peppers were first stuffed, but the tradition of filling bell peppers with all sorts of tasty fillings has taken root all over the world. And every country stuffs them in its own way, according to local traditions and available ingredients.

The most common version is bell peppers stuffed with meat and rice. Though people also stuff them with fish, vegetables, mushrooms and even cheese, especially brynza.

Stuffed peppers are even canned to make a winter stock, although these days fresh peppers are available all year round. With so many recipes, you can choose one to your taste. Stuffed peppers can be stewed, boiled, fried or baked. They can also be steamed or cooked in a microwave. All the recipes are similar, yet turn out very different. But in any case, stuffed peppers are tasty, healthy and beautiful.

At home, we usually keep stuffed peppers quite simple. Cooked rice with raw ground meat, fried onion and plenty of spices. The peppers are stuffed and cooked until done. They are served with a sweet and sour tomato sauce.

Besides the tomato sauce, which has long become traditional, sometimes we make a milk-based sauce. It is a béchamel with natural sour milk added. Such a sauce is very delicate, and the stuffed peppers get a creamy taste. Try it, I’m sure you’ll like it.

Ingredients

4 servings

  • Bell peppers 8
  • Pork 300 g
  • Onion 1
  • Rice 80 g
  • Vegetable oil 2 tbsp
  • Butter 40 g
  • Natural sour milk 0.5 l
  • Flour 3 tsp (10 g)
  • Cold boiled water to mix with 2 tsp of flour
  • Spices: salt, ground black pepper, dried savory, sweet paprika to taste
  • Ground nutmeg on the tip of a knife, optional
  • Parsley for serving

Step-by-step recipe

Preparing the peppers

  1. To make stuffed bell peppers, it’s best to choose fairly large ones, so there is enough room for the filling. Though I actually like small peppers even more.

  2. Prepare the peppers: wash them, pat dry with a napkin, then carefully pierce the skin near the stem, so the steam can escape while baking.

    Bell peppers.
  3. Roast the peppers in the oven or microwave. There is no need to bake them until completely soft, otherwise they won’t hold their shape. It’s enough for the peppers to become slightly less firm. The method of baking is up to you. But in any case, I recommend brushing the peppers with a little vegetable oil first, so the outer skin peels off better.

    Roasting the peppers.

    If you like, peel the roasted peppers of their thin, film-like skin. For microwave roasting, you can put the peppers in a loosely closed plastic bag, and the skin will slip off like a glove.

Making the filling

  1. Choose fairly fatty pork, such as shoulder or neck.

  2. Grind the meat twice in a meat grinder.

    Fatty pork.
  3. Cook the rice: rinse it thoroughly and cook until fully done. As soon as the rice is ready, drain it in a colander and rinse with cold running water.

    Choose a small-grain rice that isn’t too crumbly. Then the filling will turn out creamy.

    Rice that is not crumbly.
  4. Fry the onion. Peel and finely chop it; you can take more of it, to your taste. Fry in a little vegetable oil over medium heat until golden.

    Frying the onion.
  5. Add the ground pork and fry, stirring often, in an open pan.

    Adding the ground meat.

    Add the spices. For this amount of filling, add 0.5 tsp each of sweet ground paprika and dried savory, rubbed or crumbled. Season with salt and pepper to taste.

    Adding the spices.
  6. When the pork is browned, add the cooked rice and keep frying for another 5 minutes.

    Adding the cooked rice.

    Turn the heat down to minimum, cover the pan with a lid and simmer the filling for 10 minutes. With this method, the filling is practically ready by now.

    Simmering under the lid.

Baking the peppers

  1. Stuff the peppers with the filling, packing it in fairly tightly. Brush the stuffed peppers lightly with vegetable oil and place them in a baking dish.

    Stuffing the peppers.

    Put the dish in an oven preheated to 200°C. Cooking time is about 30 minutes. Since all ovens are different and the stuffed peppers are practically ready already, note when the juices running out start to boil and add 10 minutes; that will be enough.

Making the sauce and baking in it

  1. Make the sauce while the peppers are in the oven.

  2. Make the sauce base. Melt a piece of butter (40 g) in a frying pan. Add 1 tsp of flour (3 g) and quickly fry it, avoiding lumps. This is how the basic béchamel sauce is made.

    Frying the flour.

    Then add 0.5 l of natural sour milk. Not store-bought kefir, but natural soured milk. Of course, that’s not easy to find. But you can buy a regular carton of milk in the store, checking the shelf life first. If the shelf life is a month or three, the milk will never go sour at all. If the shelf life is a few days, the milk is much more likely to be natural. Good milk sours to the right state in a couple of days.

    Adding the sour milk.

    Season the sauce with salt and pepper to taste and add a pinch of savory. You can add a little ground nutmeg on the tip of a knife. Cook the sauce over low heat, stirring.

  3. Thicken the sauce. In a cup, mix 2 tsp of flour (7 g) with cold boiled water to make a thin batter. Strain the batter so no lumps remain. Pour it into the sauce in a thin stream, stirring constantly: the flour thickens the sauce this way. Let the sauce simmer under the lid over low heat for 5-7 minutes. The final consistency of the sauce should be like honey: thick, but still flowing.

    Sauce consistency.
  4. Take the stuffed peppers out of the oven and pour the prepared sauce over them. Move the peppers around a little with a spoon so the sauce spreads evenly.

    Pouring the sauce over the peppers.

    Put the dish back in the oven and keep baking until the sour milk sauce comes to a boil. This doesn’t take long, 10 minutes at most.

    Serving the peppers hot.

Serving

  1. Stuffed peppers get eaten while still hot, so I can’t say whether they can be eaten cold; I’ve never tried. By the way, it is very tasty sprinkled with finely chopped parsley.

    stuffed bell peppers

Calories and macros

545 kcal

Serving ≈ 450 g

  • Protein21 g16% of kcal
  • Fat34 g57% of kcal
  • Carbs35 g26% of kcal

100 g121 kcalProtein 4.7 gFat 7.4 gCarbs 7.7 g

Calculated from the recipe ingredients, excluding salt and spices. Data: USDA and Matvaretabellen.

Enjoyed the recipe? Pick me as a preferred source on Google, and you'll see my recipes more often in search. Choose on Google →
How did you like this recipe?
Thanks for rating!
Sorry you didn't like it

Leave your email and I'll write to find out what went wrong. A 1–2 rating counts only with an email. I won't publish it.

Tell us how it turned out
Made it? Tell us how it turned out — Sergey reads every review

The maximum upload file size: 10 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here