Pantesca Salad: Sicilian Potato and Tomato Salad

Pantesca Salad

☆ Rate it

The cold Sicilian appetizer known as Pantesca salad is a vegetable dish most often served with fish in oil. It comes from the island of Pantelleria, which lies between Tunisia and Sicily and is part of the Italian province of Trapani. The appetizer is often named after the island itself, Pantelleria salad. As on any Italian island or in any Italian town, the locals have plenty of patron saints, the tastiest capers, their own brand of muscat wine from Zibibbo grapes and, the pride of the islanders, Insalata Pantesca.

The base of the salad is tomatoes and boiled potatoes. Depending on the season, either new or “old” potatoes are used. The other ingredients are olives and local capers, basil and sweet onion. The salad is traditionally dressed with olive oil. Long ago it was served with dried fish; now it usually comes with mackerel in oil or sardines, and less often with various seafood.

Ingredients

2 servings

  • Potatoes 500-600 g
  • Tomatoes 300 g
  • Sweet red onion 1
  • Capers 1 tbsp (10 g)
  • Green olives 100 g
  • Fresh basil 2-3 sprigs
  • Olive oil 2-3 tbsp
  • White wine vinegar to taste
  • Salt, black pepper to taste
  • Dried oregano 1–2 pinches
  • Water for boiling the potatoes and soaking the onion
  • Mackerel in oil for serving

Step-by-step recipe

Potatoes and vegetables

It is not difficult to make Pantesca salad at home. You can use small tomatoes or large ones, whichever is in season. Buy salted capers, which work best, and green olives, preferably pitted and unstuffed. Use sweet, crisp red onion and young green basil.

  1. Boil the potatoes. You can use “new” or “old” potatoes, depending on the season.

    Use new or old potatoes.

    Peel new potatoes and boil them in salted water until a knife slides easily into the potato, then let them cool. If the potatoes are not very large, you can use them whole, which looks even nicer. Boil old potatoes in their skins and cool them in cold water. Then peel them and cut into large cubes.

    Boiling the potatoes.
  1. Put the cooled potatoes in a large salad bowl. Add a tablespoon of capers (10 g) and the olives. Cut cherry tomatoes in half and add them to the bowl. Cut large tomatoes into big cubes; you do not need to peel them or remove the seeds. Salt the salad and season with freshly ground black pepper. Also add 1–2 pinches of dried oregano.

    Mixing the boiled potatoes, tomatoes, olives and capers.
  2. Add the onion and basil. Peel the sweet red onion and cut it into very thin strips or rings. If the onion is a little sharp, soak it in ice water for 5–10 minutes, then squeeze it lightly; the sharpness will be much milder. Pick the leaves off the basil sprigs, leaving one sprig for garnish, and tear them into pieces with your fingers. Add the onion and basil to the bowl and toss the salad so all the ingredients are evenly distributed.

    Adding the onion and basil.

Dressing

  1. Dress the salad. In a small bowl or cup, mix 2–3 tbsp of olive oil, the best you have, with white wine vinegar. The proportions of oil and vinegar are up to you. Whisk the mixture with a fork, pour it over the vegetables and toss. The appetizer is ready to serve.

    Dressing the salad with olive oil and white wine vinegar.

Serving

  1. Divide the salad among small bowls and garnish with a sprig of basil. For serving, I recommend adding a few pieces of mackerel in oil, a common canned fish. Saury or sardines will do too. Since the salad was once served with dried fish, I think a piece of cold-smoked mackerel would also be excellent.

    Pantesca salad

    As a variation, you can use black olives in the salad. It will look a little different, but it will still taste good. Tuna or even fried fish will also work, and such versions are sometimes found. They say even fried chicken goes well with it.

Calories and macros

485 kcal

Serving ≈ 550 g

  • Protein8 g7% of kcal
  • Fat26 g49% of kcal
  • Carbs51 g44% of kcal

100 g88 kcalProtein 1.5 gFat 4.6 gCarbs 9.2 g

Calculated from the recipe ingredients, excluding salt and spices. Data: USDA and Matvaretabellen.

Enjoyed the recipe? Pick me as a preferred source on Google, and you'll see my recipes more often in search. Choose on Google →

How did you like this recipe?

Thanks for rating!
Sorry you didn't like it

Leave your email and I'll write to find out what went wrong. A 1–2 rating counts only with an email. I won't publish it.

Tell us how it turned out

Made it? Tell us how it turned out — Sergey reads every review

The maximum upload file size: 10 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here